Randomly inspired by a fic I just reblobbed:
So, in my Legit Hawke playthrough (Abigael Hawke where Curtis died at Ostagar), Carver dies because he goes to the deep roads and Anders doesn’t come along.
In Abi’s solo timeline, she is a spirit healer (admittedly not a good one), but good enough to stop most people dying.
So she doesn’t really need Anders for his healing ability.
She’s got to take Varric, so that’s one slot down. (Stupid slot mechanic – why can’t Varric be an additional necessity like Anders and Bela in their quests???)
Carver and Abi get on pretty well and she knows how much he doesn’t want a) to be left alone and b) to let Abigael go without him to back her up.
So that’s slot two filled!
Finally, as Abi doesn’t count Anders healing skill as needed, it’s only is grey warden -ness that makes him a good idea. And he hates the deep roads and Abi doesn’t want to hurt him (they’re damn good friends by this point).
Additionally, Carver is pure damage, so there’s no tank or melee support for him yet and seeing as Aveline is now Captain, Abi doesn’t want to take her away.
Leaving Bela, Fenris or Merrill.
I can’t see Bela wanting to come along and Merrill doesn’t add anything that Abi as a mage doesn’t cover.
Leaving Fenris, who definitely wants to come to repay his debt to Abi and also because for all their differences, Fenris definitely cares about her and even Carver to some degree.
So Fenris wants to come, can support Carver as a melee fighter and isn’t a squishy mage
Vs
Anders doesn’t want to come, is a squishy mage and isn’t needed for his healing only his grey warden spidey senses.
So Fenris comes.
And Carver dies.
Sorry Carver.


